BNET Insight

Sales Machine

A, Always. B, Be. C, Closing.

In Academia, Sales Can't Get No Respect.

July 2nd, 2007 @ 5:51 am

5 Comments

Categories: General

Tags: Sales, Geoffrey James

The term “sales pro” may be apt, but colleges still treat selling (at best) like a marketing’s bastard stepchild. The failure to recognize the importance of selling skills in every aspect of life-not just business-is a perfect example of what’s wrong with today’s academic community.

Let’s take inventory. According to the U.S. Department of Education, over the past decade, U.S. colleges and universities have awarded approximately 1.1 million MBAs. Guess how many of those graduated MBAs took even a single course in Sales? Answer: less than 1 percent. Guess how many of those MBAs were awarded with a concentration in Sales? Answer: Zero (or so close it makes no difference). Guess how many colleges offer even a minor in Sales as part of an undergraduate business degree? Less than 40 — out of several thousand institutions.

What gives? Why is Sales a pariah when it comes to academia?

It can’t be because Sales is an “art” and therefore not appropriate for colleges to teach. After all, during the same period of time, colleges awarded 73,882 masters degrees in English Literature and 30,118 in Liberal Arts, a major that encompasses sculpting and oil painting. And it can’t be because Sales is a “people skill” and therefore not appropriate for colleges to teach, since they managed to award 160,786 masters degrees in Psychology, the vast majority of which will be used in counseling rather than research. And it can’t because Sales is too airy-fairy and vague to be a valid subject matter, since they awarded 14,195 masters in Philosophy/Religion, not to mention 15,582 in Gender Studies (???).

Why does Sales get short shrift when it comes to higher education? Two reasons:

First, business schools are dominated by Marketing professionals who have a vested interest in minimizing the importance of Sales. For a marketing professional, the ideal world is one where there is no need for Sales because consumers buy products directly from manufacturers. Because they’re so enamored of “frictionless commerce,” they completely miss the point that B2B consultative sales is the only way for customers to make sense of the insane complexity of the modern business world. Marketing, as currently taught, is the enemy of Sales and they’re not going to let the enemy on their turf.

Second, academia, in general, considers commerce unclean. Outside of business schools, academia thinks of business as something that corrupts youth, turning them away from important life pursuits, like learning the history of proto-feminism in 12th century (or whatever). They’ll tolerate business schools because they bring in a lot of money, but launching Sales as a separate academic discipline would force academics to confront their own overwhelming hypocrisy. After all, when it comes to winning grant money and alumni donations, academics are the biggest whores on the planet. As such, the last thing they’d want is to trumpet that their school is good at teaching people to sell.

This would all just be mildly annoying if it weren’t for the fact that the unwillingness of colleges to treat Sales a serious profession has two negative outcomes:

First, it’s created a sales training industry where there’s no quality control or standards of performance. While there are some great sales training firms out there, the sad truth is that companies waste billions of dollars every year on sales programs that are basically useless entertainment.

Second, the lack of a real sales focus in colleges has made it difficult or impossible for sales pros to make the case that they’re professionals, who should be considered as professional as doctors, lawyers, and marketing drones with MBAs. The consequent lack of social standing encourages the obsolete and insulting notion that sales pros are simply hucksters in business suits.

What’s frustrating about the situation is that there isn’t a profession in the world where the ability to sell isn’t an absolute requirement for success. While they’ll pretend it isn’t so, even doctors and lawyers have to run businesses by selling their services to the public. Artist, musicians, writers and sculptors, if they plan to work in their field of choice, had better learn to sell or they won’t eat. Engineers and scientists have to sell their ideas to win money for research and development. As for the horde of psychologists, philosophers, pastors, and “gender studies” experts that colleges extrude each year from their ivy-covered hallways - all of them will have to convince people that they provide a salable service.

In short, everyone sells. Everyone. There is no life skill more valuable and more important than learning how to sell. That’s why it’s madness that colleges and universities continue to treat Sales as if it didn’t exist.

This Blog's Best Post: The Ultimate Cold Calling Tool

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    gerold1

    07/02/07 | Report as spam

    Needed: A PhD in Sales.

    isn't "show neediness" bad behaviour in sales? wink

  •  
    2

    JohnOnSales

    07/02/07 | Report as spam

    sales phd?

    I don't think a PhD is appropriate, but I think one or two courses in selling ought to be required in an undergraduate business program. And, I think MBA programs ought to offer sales/sales management as an area of specialty. My life would have been infinitely easier if my MBA program had required a course in selling (like they required for statistics and HR). As it is, I also had to wade through hundreds of books and thousands of dollars to get the info that I needed to be successful. xoxoxo JohnOnSales

  •  
    3

    juniorbird

    07/06/07 | Report as spam

    A way in

    I encountered this problem while getting my MBA. As I dug deeper, I found that the entrepreneurship department had a lot of sales advocates in it. As b-schools get more practical, this could be the way in to the curriculum. The students themselves aren't against it. Even better, call up your local school and offer to do a half-day seminar. Let the profs see what you can do and how much the students love it.

  •  
    4

    mtalleyrand

    07/22/07 | Report as spam

    In Academia, What Pays the Bills Gets Respect

    If there is a market for a major or degree program in sales, such a major or program will exist in short order.

    Administration will make sure of it the moment they know there is a sustainable market for it, or think there might be.

    Professors (like me) don't have the kind of power you fancy we do to stop a program that has a constituency from coming into existence.

    Likewise, if there are companies or foundations who want to fund research in sales, the research will happen, and that will lead to teaching.

    At least that's how it is at the shop where I work. I think you'll find it's that way pretty much everywhere.

    No need to be so fired up about it. Just show the administration at your local franchise of the Ivory Tower that there's a market for a sales program, and there will be one.

  •  
    5

    Geoffrey James, Sales Machine

    07/29/09 | Report as spam

    RE: In Academia, Sales Can't Get No Respect.

    Email from a reader:


    Geoffrey:
    Thank YOU for writing such a powerful, fact based article. You article is the ammunition I wish we had in 1995 when I pulled together 30 of my friends from Xerox, P&G, Gartner Group and other sales professionals to form The Sales Centre at OHIO Unversity in Athens, OH.
    The Sales Centre sales certificate candidates and alumni are setting all kinds of records in their early sales careers and even winning the National Collegiate Sales Competition at Kennesaw State this past February...our two competitors won 1st and 2nd in all rounds of 128 competitors. So, The Sales Centre is getting some respect in academia. But, since one of our primary goals in starting the Sales Centre was to illustrate that Sales is an honorable and necessary PROFESSION we need your facts to SELL sales to Academia.
    Thanks again.
    PS: I spent 30 years at Xerox, mostly utilizing XEROX PARC inventions to revoluntize business processes so I was intrigqued that your background is based in technology not carrying a bag!
    Thanks again and best always!
    I am one of your new fans and I will be referring to your work often in my new blog, web sites, social media tools and national speaking engagments.
    Best always!

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement

Blogger Profiles

  • Blogger Thumbnail Geoffrey James Geoffrey James has sold and written hundreds of features, articles and columns for national publications including Wired, Men's Health, Business 2.0, SellingPower, Brand World, Computer Gaming World, CIO, The New York Times and (of course) BNET. He is the author of seven books, including Business Wisdom of the Electronic Elite (translated into seven languages and selected by four book clubs), and The Tao of Programming (widely quoted on the Web as a "canonical book of... more »

advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement
Click Here