BNET Insight

Sales Machine

A, Always. B, Be. C, Closing.

The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

October 29th, 2008 @ 4:15 am

20 Comments

Categories: General, Management, Marketing, Rant, Sales Technology, Watercooler

Tags: Customer, Sales Professional, Internet, Sales Strategy, Sales Force Management, Sales, Geoffrey James

Myth: The Internet makes customers so well informed that they no longer need sales professionals to help them make business decisions.

Truth: The Internet frequently creates confusion and ignorance, thus producing a demand for highly-skilled sales professionals.

I realize that this truth is difficult for some folk to swallow, but it’s true nonetheless.

Please note that I’m not saying that a customer can’t learn about your product set by reading stuff that’s on the Internet. I just question whether they know what to do with all the data that they can find.

Customers doing research on the web, on any subject of complexity, are prone to fall prey to one or more of the following four pitfalls:

  • PITFALL #1: Information Overload.  The more information that’s available, the more important it is to have the ability to sort out the wheat from the chaff.  (Or, in some cases, the needle from the haystack.)  Specifically in B2B sales, there’s now so much information slopping around about many products that it could take years to sort it all out.  While customers have access to plenty of information (i.e. product features, comparison pricing, customer complaints etc.), many just see all that data as an undifferentiated blur of meaningless facts. Conversely, some customers believe they can learn about a subject by reading a few articles and trolling through a forum, when in fact they’ve just swallowed whatever random information was popped up first.
  • PITFALL #2: Toxic Anonymity.  In the past, most people simply ignored anonymous sources.  On the Internet, comments that in the past would probably have been thrown in the trash are exalted to the level of “market research.” Because anonymous people can’t be held accountable, they make comments that are off-the-wall, or full of self-serving lies.  For example, John P. Mackey, the co-founder of Whole Foods Market, created an anonymous online persona and posted over a thousand entries on Yahoo Finance’s bulletin board, many of which criticized a competitor.  Customers of that competitor (in this case investors) may have very well made decisions based upon the “data” in those anonymous posts.
  • PITFALL #3: Imitation Expertise.  If you read 1,000 encyclopedias and have a photographic memory, you’ve filled your mind with data, but that data is useless unless you can differentiate between what’s important and what’s not, and what’s accurate and what’s not.  Expertise, which comes from experience and judgment, allows you to understand how data fits into the larger world.  Customer who lacks expertise are unable to differentiate between fact and opinion, between irrelevant detail and important concepts.  When customers simply seize upon whatever “makes sense,” they’re worse off than before, because they think that they are experts when in fact they’ve only lost the self-realization that they’re still basically ignorant.
  • PITFALL #4: Information Pollution.  It’s been repeated endlessly that the Internet is “democratizing” the media — as if that were a good thing.  What democratization has really done is created a situation where any pinhead can pose as an expert — and most people can’t tell the difference.  As a result, there’s a wealth of bad information available on the web.  Rumors fly around with the speed of light.  Fake news stories get treated as if they are real.   The result can be hoaxes that cost companies billions of dollars, like the famous Y2K “disaster” scenarios.  As a result, much of the information on the web is polluted with opinion masquerading as fact, content that has a hidden agenda, and downright lies.

In other words, far from making customers more informed, the Internet can make them more confused.

And that’s really good news for sales professionals.  I explain why in the post “B2B Sales Pros Make Customers Smarter.”

This Blog's Best Post: The Ultimate Cold Calling Tool

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    dareconcrete

    10/30/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    Internet is the greater mechanism to initiate a prospect follow up sale call.

  •  
    2

    Geoffrey James, Sales Machine

    10/30/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    QUOTE: Internet is the greater mechanism to initiate a prospect follow up sale call.

    Absolutely. It's a fantastic PROSPECTING tool. But that's the other side of the equation. It's not always a great way for the customer to find out the right information. Information at your fingertips doesn't mean that it's the right information, after all...

  •  
    3

    ennyman

    10/30/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    It's not either or.... Wikipedia and Google are remarkable tools for providing certain info fast. For example, I saw a Thomas Carlyle quote and wanted to know more about him. I do not need to go to a library any more. Wikipedia gives me all I need just so I have an anchor to associate him with a time frame, etc.
    But yes, I have written a couple articles about info overload and it is an issue. There are things people SHOULD be learning about (like how to take car of their cars) and they are so overwhelmed with learning new useless information that they don't even know to check their oil.
    Consumers need help. ... but they are not stupid.

    As for toxic anonymity... Isn't it "buyer beware" here? I mean, a little "applied critical thinking" is also necessary in this game.... The more that is at stake, well, the more one needs to use some sense. One bad decision may be a little costly, but isn't that unfortunately the price of an education sometimes.

    It's a "wild west" out there in cyberspace, but I don't think we want to go back to three networks controlling the entire flow of information in the world... or six publishers or whatever.

    I am not disagreeing with the premises... am only preaching a little personal responsibility here. We can't blame the internet or Google any more than addicts can blame the devil...
    e.

  •  
    4

    Marsha Keeffer

    10/30/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    Rubicon Consulting just published a study that customers' second most used way of gaining purchasing information is via online reviews and comments....it's second only to word of mouth.

    The data now prove that online reviews and comments are influencers that actually surpass PR placements, advertising and manufacturer information. Online is crucial.

    View the entire study at http://tinyurl.com/5peaov

  •  
    5

    taxh8tr

    10/30/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    You're joking...

    Salespeople are rarely experts and they are obviously biased. The role of the sales person now is to verify the mapping of their product to the customer's requirements and to negotiate pricing. Anyone who weighs the input of a salesperson over the wealth of information on the Internet is simply to lazy or insecure to weed through the research and make decisions.

  •  
    6

    Geoffrey James, Sales Machine

    10/30/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    QUOTE from taxh8tr: Salespeople are rarely experts and they are obviously biased.


    You're in error. Sales reps who aren't experts in their field -- and in their customer's business, simply can't function in today's B2B sales environments.



    QUOTE from taxh8tr: verify the mapping of their product to the customer's requirements and to negotiate pricing.


    Once again, you're in error. B2B sales reps define/frame problems, build solutions, and then own the results of that solution. They're outsourcers, not order-takers.



    QUOTE from taxh8tr: Anyone who weighs the input of a salesperson over the wealth of information on the Internet is simply to lazy or insecure to weed through the research and make decisions.


    This isn't so much an error as just extraordinary naivete on your part. Any manager who tries to be an expert in dozens of areas that are outside the core competency of his own firm should be fired. In most cases, if the manager figures out how to save money, it's not enough to justify the extra work of doing all the research.



    I deal with these issues in detail in the post:



    B2B Sales Pros Make Customers Smarter


    http://blogs.bnet.com/salesmachine/?p=570


  •  
    7

    Geoffrey James, Sales Machine

    10/30/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    QUOTE: The data now prove that online reviews and comments are influencers that actually surpass PR placements, advertising and manufacturer information.

    Irrelevant. As I've pointed out numerous times, almost all marketing materials (i.e. PR, advertising and manufacturer info, aka brochures) are now, and have always been, useless as sales tools. The question is whether managers should be trying to become experts in everything that they purchase. Manager who do so (and there are apparently many) are being foolish with their time. I note that you don't say how many of these forum-browsing buyers were led astray by false reviews, bogus comments, and information bloat.

  •  
    8

    Engago Team

    10/31/08 | Report as spam

    Not: The customer knows more than the salesman

    The salesman has many products to sell and know about.
    The customer is interested in one single product and knows about the nearest models of the competitor as he has studied the Internet on several occasions.
    http://bit.ly/3eyM5z
    The buyer knows more than the salesman.
    And that can make or break the decision to buy with a vendor, as the buyer finds out he knows more.
    The customer has never been so informed as now, making him capable of shifting between serious salesmen and other.

  •  
    9

    Geoffrey James, Sales Machine

    10/31/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    QUOTE: The salesman has many products to sell and know about. The customer is interested in one single product and knows about the nearest models of the competitor

    You have it exactly backwards. A successful sales rep is the expert in his product area and usually understands the competition thoroughly. Similarly, the customer knows about HIS business function and needs to focus on it to be successful. If he doesn't he's wasting his time. Please read:

    B2B Sales Pros Make Customers Smarter
    http://blogs.bnet.com/salesmachine/?p=570

  •  
    10

    Engago Team

    10/31/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    @Geoffrey
    That's why all current investigations now mention people first trust the word of mouth from their friends and in second place the information they retrieved from the Internet.
    Where does this leave the Salesman?

    Currently when a customer enters a shop or a company employee is buying, he is informed and knowledgeable on the matter.
    In some cases during the selection process of purchase customers phone home to someone sitting at home in front of his PC investigating the Internet on the 2 or 3 possible models to buy.

    In many cases the potential customer knows more than the salesman who isn't aware of all possible new developments in the market.

  •  
    11

    mmello

    10/31/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    Oh really?

    Well, it's so comforting to know the world is full of un-biased, honest and knowledgeable salespeople to help us, ignorant buyers, out of our web-induced mental blurr.

    Thank you.

    Maybe you should get out of the Web and go back to the streets informing and illuminating confounded professional buyers (poor helpless folks they are).

  •  
    12

    Geoffrey James, Sales Machine

    10/31/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    The previous two comments are based upon a world where companies buy products that fit into their vision of what needs to happen in their companies.



    How 1990s!



    Only idiots buy B2B products and try to cobble them into solutions by hand when you can find a sales rep who will do the job for you, if not for free, then at least for far less than you'd be able to do it yourself.



    If everyone in the world thought like Engago Team and mmello, then Microsoft would not only make software, but build its own computers, build its own circuit boards, design its own semiconductors, construct it's own fabrication machines, and so on, all the way down to mining the copper that goes into the wires.



    No company, and no person, can possible understand EVERYTHING that goes into running a modern globalized business. People who think that the Internet gives them this power are simply deluding themselves.

  •  
    13

    Engago Team

    11/01/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    @Geoffrey Microsoft: Samsung makes alomost everything themselves: Their mobile phones are the best example and they are #2 behind Nokia.

    But this has nothing to do with Internet making custoemr stupid.

    About salesman helping out: the main drive for a salesman is his commission. Thus why put the future of your company in the hands of someone on a comission.
    People will retrieve information from multiple sales people and compare it with their own perception they made by advice from friends and colleages or what they have found on the Internet (or a combination).
    If aalesman tells a too different story or benefit, he will have a hard time to convince.

    Just wondering:
    - Why do you blog?
    - Have you already experienced your blogging power?
    - Were you impressed of your power?
    - Your blogging on the Internet is to make customers stupid?

  •  
    14

    Geoffrey James, Sales Machine

    11/01/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    QUOTE from Engago: About salesman helping out: the main drive for a salesman is his commission.

    You obviously know nothing about sales or sales professionals. They are not sub-human money grubbers, but are motivated in as many different ways, and by as many different things, as other people. Maybe when you've gain some perspective beyond cultural stereotypes, you'll be able to understand what I'm talking about in these posts.



    As for your questions, I'm not selling anything on this blog. Nada. The question isn't whether there are reliable source of information on the web, because there are many such sources. The question is whether it makes sense for a manager to spend days researching some complex subject matter rather than getting a sales pro to do it for him, for less money than it would take the manager to do it himself.



    It's called delegation. But since you're convinced that sales professionals are professional leeches, you'll never be able to see the simple logic of this idea.

  •  
    15

    ndlicht1

    11/01/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    The flaw in internet research is that anything can get onto the internet without passing any validity or truth testing. Folks seem to see and believe all kinds of things and then pass them along as truth yet they have never checked the truth of the statements they pass on.

    Internet research can get you a feel for an area but decisionmaking - not without being an "expert" in deployment and having the education that can validate or devalidate what you find.

    Commodity type products can be purchased via internet since its usually a price only difference but beyond commodity typr stuff where a keen understanding of a business and how to define a solution to their issues- thats just not on the internet at all. Sales people are still the key.

  •  
    16

    Geoffrey James, Sales Machine

    11/01/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    QUOTE for ndlicht: The flaw in internet research ... are still the key.

    Thank you, Neil, for explaining so clearly in three paragraphs what I've been struggling to explain using two longish posts.

  •  
    17

    shoub

    11/02/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    Customers will be critical thinkers or idiots with or without the Internet.

    You don't need a sales person to buy a book from Amazon. But if you spend 2 million dollars on a real estate deal strictly on the basis of an on-line property listing, then that's your problem.

    Managers do NOT spend untold hours on the Net. They either view the top 10 on a search or delegate the task to an underling.

    Actually, sales people are not as releveant as they used to be. Pre & post-sale support staff and Account Managers are far more important these days.

  •  
    18

    marinmikulic

    11/02/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    I must contradict with the author's opinions:
    Webinfo does not make people's minds more polluted with info. IT makes them more tolerant and up to date with other people's opinions.
    This now said, I conclude that all on the Internet needn't be facts, that is not their purpose whatsoever, it is the variety of opinions.

  •  
    19

    Geoffrey James, Sales Machine

    11/02/08 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    QUOTE: IT makes them more tolerant

    I think you're being a bit naive here. When religious nuts uses the Internet, they connects with other religious nuts and quickly become 1) more religious and 2) more nutty.

  •  
    20

    jenilia

    07/17/09 | Report as spam

    RE: The Internet Can Make Customers Stupid

    It is partiaally real becaz i use the AT&T internet connection my system is very very slow they said the connection fast But now is Become slow i use the site for the Internet speed testhttp://www.ip-details.com/

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement

Blogger Profiles

  • Blogger Thumbnail Geoffrey James Geoffrey James has sold and written hundreds of features, articles and columns for national publications including Wired, Men's Health, Business 2.0, SellingPower, Brand World, Computer Gaming World, CIO, The New York Times and (of course) BNET. He is the author of seven books, including Business Wisdom of the Electronic Elite (translated into seven languages and selected by four book clubs), and The Tao of Programming (widely quoted on the Web as a "canonical book of... more »

advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement
Click Here