BNET Insight

BNET Intercom

News and observations from the BNET staff

Run Away from Running These Businesses

August 31st, 2009 @ 9:49 am

17 Comments

Categories: BNET, Career, Management, economy

Tags: Entrepreneur, Entrepreneurship, Management, Stefan Deeran

Ready to escape the corporate world and work for yourself?  America certainly tries to support its entrepreneurs, setting aside billions of dollars in federal contracts specifically for small businesses.

But securing your first financial boost is only one of your challenges.  First you have to pick a business that can be realistically turned into a profitable operation. And if you pick one of these seven common businesses, you may struggle to see your dream come true, according to Yahoo!:

  • Restaurants: Managers must wrestle with low profit margins and seasonal fluctuations
  • Direct Sales: High earners are often just sitting atop pyramid schemes
  • Online Retail: Good luck competing with eBay or Amazon
  • High-End Retail: The recession has thwarted conspicuous consumption
  • Independent Consulting: Many consultants spend so much time scouting work that it’s very difficult to earn steady income
  • Franchise Ownership: It’s a myth that franchises are far more successful than independent businesses
  • Traffic-Driven Web Sites: You’ll need a million page views a day before you can make a living off advertising

Do you agree with Yahoo!’s list?  Do most entrepreneurs end up launching businesses that are the cheapest and easiest to start, not necessarily the ones best suited to thrive in the marketplace?  Share your thoughts below.

Stefan Deeran consults environmental advocacy groups and businesses on their sustainability strategies and communications plans. He also publishes the online newsmagazine the Exception.
 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    Bouchart

    08/31/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    This sounds about right.

  •  
    2

    Ian P

    09/01/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    The big problem with this list is that they are service economy industries which live off rather than directly benefit the economy. Although you can always point to instant successes like 'Hotforwords.com' that make their owners rich and relatively famous, they don't really add much to real life.
    These are easy industries to start up in but also easy to fail in leaving most people and the taxpayer so much poorer on average.
    Both our economies (UK and US) need entrepreneurs that will develop the next generation of industries to replace the likes of Boeing, GM and Microsoft. Industries that will firstly beat off imports and later become household brand exports.
    This is where taxpayers money should be targeted - not the fluff economy.

  •  
    3

    jburkepe

    09/01/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    Interesting list, and definitely food for thought. But I think it misses the point (as does the original Yahoo article) - are these businesses overrated because they are especially hard? Any business is at risk of failure (or at least severe misery) if done improperly or with inadequate planning. Indeed, the Yahoo article quotes a SCORE executive in describing the difficulty. SBA and SCORE are great resources and offer a significant reality check for anyone contemplating an entrepreneurial venture.

    The quote from the article says it all: "A successful consulting firm needs people to find the work, grind out the work and mind the work. Unless you know you can do all three yourself, you potentially expose your business to great risk." Except that "consulting firm" could be replaced by virtually any endeavor - whether providing goods or services.

    Write a business plan, study the market, and foster the business manager side that must be present in every entrepreneur. If you need help, visit SCORE, hire some outside help, or rethink your motivation for starting your own business.

  •  
    4

    DeniseCorc

    09/01/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    Any business that has low barriers to entry will always be
    more competitive and much harder to thrive in.

    I am not convinced of your conclusions about any
    entrepreneur who wants to launch a business to steer clear
    of the above list. To me, aside from having low barriers to
    entry, the above businesses are usually populated with
    those who have no clue about business or marketing. Nor
    are they hungry enough nor disciplined nor clear on how
    they differentiate themselves to make their businesses
    successful.

    When I started my consulting business in 1985 (and yes, I'm
    still around and thriving 25 years later), I knocked on lots of
    corporate doors and did not let up till I got clients. I found
    if I gave over the top value that was measurable to their
    bottomline and goals, they became loyal, long-term
    partners and clients for many years.

    In my experience, many consultants who adopt these
    practices and also develop multiple streams of income, as I
    have, not only survive but have booming businesses.

    And yes, I agree with the above post, you must develop a
    biz plan, research market and build relationships that serve
    above all else.

    Denise Corcoran
    The Empowered Business (tm)
    denise@empoweredbusiness.com


  •  
    5

    rajesh.alla

    09/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    I cannot start a business unless:
    1) I see and define a clear NEED in the market that I will address
    2) I define the unique VALUE that I bring to the market over and above what is being provided by the existing players addressing similar needs
    3) I define where my CASH comes from in the next two years to cater to my operations

  •  
    6

    DebF

    09/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    I'm surprised you didn't include estate agents!

  •  
    7

    dos12286

    09/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    I'm not reading articles by this guy anymore its obvious he's never owned a business. Low profit margins in restaurants? Does he know how much it cost to make a bowl of pasta vs.how much it sells for? "Its a myth franchises are more successful..." Yeah its just dumb luck they're all over the place.

    Don't start a high end retail store because of the recession! Yeah its smart to be short-term oriented in business. I can't believe BNET lets guys like this write for them. Just another guy who follows the herd. Whats next? Don't start a GM dealership!

  •  
    8

    dzimmer821

    09/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    In my first year as a Franchisee I watched two sister Franchises near me go down the tubes.(I did very well) One new and one 3 years old. It was clear they had no clue what they were getting into or what was needed to run the business. I think without a plan, commitment, knowledge and money any businees will fail. I think if franchises fail it is a result of the franchisee not the franchise. There are too many successful ones.

  •  
    9

    4adams

    09/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    The question is, do people fail in these businesses because of
    the businesses themselves, or because they are unqualified or
    unprepared for them? Since starting your own business
    removes the gatekeepers of corporate HR who will typically
    weed out the unqualified, anyone can start a business. Some
    people who start businesses in the seven areas listed above
    are fantastically successful, having what it takes to run a
    business, so we have to ask whether it is about the kind of
    business or the kind of person that creates success.

    I would be curious to see the flip-side of this list. What are
    the seven businesses to get into that are close to sure-thing,
    where you can start a business with typically low failure
    rates. I think you'll have a hard time putting that list
    together!

  •  
    10

    makkh@...

    09/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    Let me try to list some of the flip examples?

    1. Services / consultations which requires skills or knowledge (eg. tech support)
    2. Unique business which not many people explore before
    3. Add in value product / services where additional ideas are inserted to increase customers satisfaction

    I believe with combination of above mentioned, you can come out plenty of brilliant business idea which will spark out others!

  •  
    11

    Ian P

    09/03/09 | Report as spam

    Businesses that it is hard to fail in

    Defence
    Medicine
    Construction
    Law
    Finance

    Why are they hard to fail in?
    Because they all have high costs or barriers to entry and operate in closed markets.
    But once you are in there - WOW is there a lot of money to be made!!

  •  
    12

    qualitymgt04@...

    09/03/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    I would suggest that 'Traffic-Driven Web Sites' can be the notable exception on this list. The fact is, there are many variables that must be considered, among them . . .

    - Is their offer a desirable product or service (i.e., is there proven demand for that which is being marketed)?
    - Do product margins justify corresponding efforts when assessed in light of gross sales projections? What process yielded such projections?
    - Is there in place a competent and comprehensive set of business processes, from that of eliciting traffic through those of post-sale support (where appropriate)?

    Today it is relatively simple and inexpensive to 'hang out one's shingle' by setting up an online business. For this reason, there are many that do. Unfortunately, as with the well-quoted statistics concerning the high failure rate among small businesses, similar rates of failure are surely evidenced for online businesses - and for likely the same reasons.

    With respect to virtually any business, the value of a business plan cannot be overemphasized. The most well understood purpose for a business plan is the role it serves when used to secure capital for a business. While this may prove necessary, the planning process itself, for an entrepreneur, can yield the greatest results.

    Through an active [and appropriate] business planning process, an entrepreneur should become intimately familiar with matters that are critical to the success of the business under consideration. Disciplined thinking, understanding and the 'new' knowledge generated through the process should clarify the entrepreneur's vision and increase their competencies to a degree that is consistent with their efforts and thoroughness.

    I suggest that the most important 'product' of a quality business planning process is not the documentation that is produced; but rather, the entrepreneurs and related stakeholders that participated in its creation that are far more prepared to think and act decisively towards the successful ends of the business venture. This holds true whether a business is slated to exist online or offline.

    One must 'become' who they need to be to run a successful enterprise and must therefore acquire understanding of what is required. A business plan serves a focal point for activities with promise to answer 'the critical questions' that lead to such knowledge . . . and means to document such knowledge for future reference and for communication among relevant stakeholders.

    As for 'Traffic-Driven Websites,' there are those who enter business without adequate preparation. Lacking a sufficiently comprehensive understanding of their venture, it should be no surprise that in such cases results may prove disappointing. Through appropriate preparation and understanding however, entrepreneurs may avoid common mistakes, leverage what works [i.e., apply best practices], and position their online business venture with far higher promise of yielding desirable results.

    For those who would wish to implement a 'Traffic-Driven Website' without thinking things through thoroughly, without identifying and addressing each factor critical to its success, then I would agree that, for you, the existence of this on the 'list of 5' is indeed correct and that this is likely a business opportunity that you should avoid.

    For those who are willing to do what is necessary to position your business for success, then by all means I would suggest to go about doing so. Invest your time and energy into developing the knowledge required to create your business plan. Plan your work, then work your plan. The results can certainly prove worthwhile. While doing so, I suggest that you guard who you listen to - and evaluate for yourself who is and is not qualified to render advice/guidance, etc. Many an entrepreneurial venture has been killed through comments rendered by those with the best of intentions.


  •  
    13

    Susan R Berg

    09/12/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    An important element of any work is the passion and skill
    you bring to it. People enter crowded markets every day,
    and who succeeds? The ones who love their work, because
    the effort they put into it is a labor of love.

    Does this mean you succeed every time? No. There's
    always an element of timing and serendipity. My biggest
    question about entrepreneurship is -- do you love this work
    enough to put the elbow grease into it to make it work? If
    that answer is yes, then the next question is do you have
    the skills, or can you get them? If that answer is yes, then
    go for it.

    If you'd like to continue this conversation about doing work
    you love, join us at a related blog at ChooseOnPurpose.com.

  •  
    14

    paulomugohk

    09/23/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    about traffic driven websites...revolutionary ideas like targeting highly specific consumer niches and social networking are making make are stringing in ad revenue...teh ones you talk about websites that are to general, like bnet perhaps.

  •  
    15

    dzimmer821

    09/24/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    I don't know if you have to love "the business" you are in but maybe the collateral processes. I have a tax franchise and I don't 'love' doing taxes but I really enjoy the interactions with clients and helping them through what is for most people an unpleasant experience. The software does the taxes, but you get a much different bottom line if you ask questions and discover what deductions, credits etc. them may be eligible for and in the process get to know the people. To me thats the fun part and keeps a smile on my face when I go to work.

  •  
    16

    Susan R Berg

    09/25/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    Dear dzimmer821 and BNET folks,

    As I see it, no work offers 100% fun. The important part is
    finding work that you really want to get up for every day.
    At the end of the day we all want to feel like we made a
    difference, that there's something that wouldn't have
    happened that day if we didn't make it so.

    Loving the work is different from loving the "business", if I
    understand you. After all, what makes one coffee shop
    work and not the other? I usually comes down to service
    (the interactions you enjoy, as you say) and a good cup of
    coffee. If you don't love coffee and listening to people's
    stories, you probably won't pay as much attention to the
    details of a good cup of java or a meaningful customer
    conversation that keeps bringing 'em back.
    Yours, Susan Berg, www.ChooseOnPurpose.com

  •  
    17

    linusjf

    11/06/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Run Away from Running These Businesses

    Traffic-driven web-sites , would have to be something really big like say Facebook or Google for you to make a living off the advertising revenue. The simple fact is that it is click-thru ads i.e. when the visitor to the site clicks through to actually visit the advertising businesses web-site. Also, if someone is at your web-site , however sticky , it may be, only a minute percentage of people actually click on the ads displayed. Say, if you have 100 visitors, if you're lucky , then 5 may click through to the ads displayed. Thus, you need volumes to make your traffic-driven site pay for itself. Else, good luck !

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement