BNET Insight

BNET Intercom

News and observations from the BNET staff

Should You Hire the More Beautiful Candidate? Ask an Economist

January 3rd, 2008 @ 11:48 am

3 Comments

Categories: Career, General, Research, Workplace

Tags: Economist, Beauty, Dr Hamermesh, Professional Development, Financial Accounting, Career, Finance, Jessica Stillman

Should You Hire the More Beautiful Candidate? Ask an EconomistBeauty and business are not necessarily topics you’d think of as going together, but most of us have heard of studies linking good looks and career advancement. It certainly doesn’t seem fair, but is it true? In a strange choice of Christmas special, the Economist recently took a look at the issue. Not known for its sensationalist reporting, the magazine nonetheless came up with some pretty startling (and disillusioning) conclusions. Among their most galling findings: dumb blond jokes aside, beauty is actually correlated with intelligence.

The Economist cites a study by Dr. Daniel Hamermesh of the University of Texas:

The accumulating evidence suggests that physical characteristics do give clues about intelligence, that such clues are picked up by other people, and that these clues are also associated with beauty. And other work also suggests that this really does matter…. [Dr Hamermesh] has collected evidence from more than one continent that beauty really is associated with success—at least, with financial success. He has also shown that, if all else is equal, it might be a perfectly legitimate business strategy to hire the more beautiful candidate.

Even more unfairly, Dr Hamermesh found evidence that beautiful people may bring more revenue to their employers than the less-favored do.

Beauty may matter for business, but can’t the less naturally graced make up for biology with a little effort and a credit card? Dr. Hamermesh, unfortunately, dashed that hope as well.

Can you really fake the unfakeable signal? Dr Hamermesh’s research suggests that you can but, sadly, that it is not cost-effective—at least, not if your purpose is career advancement… he looked at how women’s spending on their cosmetics and clothes affected their income. The answer was that it did, but not enough to pay for itself in a strictly financial sense.

Thanks Economist for that cheery Christmas special.

(Image of blond woman by reportergimmi, CC 2.0)

 

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    darinp

    01/04/08 | Report as spam

    Sex Sells

    You can report the findings from research at the University of New Mexico and the University of Texas as disappointing, but it should not come as a surprise to anyone. Marketing has long held that "sex sells". In some countries (e.g. Chile) it is common practice to put your photograph on your resume. In fact, without a photo your resume will be rejected. History is also full of stories of people who were born into poverty, but broke free of their class to end up married to a wealthy person. Of course, some of those same stories help us realize that some talents (especially musical ability) can also help you break free of the barriers that often hinder unattractive people. Think of all of the supermodels that married ugly musicians during the 1980's...
    I think you missed the real point from the Economist article because you seemed so focused on your dismay at how superficial we all are. It is not about being superficial - it is about the fact that many beautiful people are actually also very smart people. And you missed the point that beauty comes from being symetrical and from being healthy. We may be in a period of enlightenment in many people's eyes, but we are still animals with instincts. Those instincts can serve you well if you let them guide some of your decisions - even in business.

  •  
    2

    Archana Shrivastava

    01/04/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Should You Hire the More Beautiful Candidate? Ask an Economist

    Good loks are certainly the key requirements in certain jobs but not all. Beauty is a very personal perception and as such varies frm person to person . Hiring of candidated should be based on proper job evaluation and rational assesment of the candidate.

  •  
    3

    smwilliams1986

    01/22/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Should You Hire the More Beautiful Candidate? Ask an Economist

    This is a neverending topic, but a person should be hired on qualifications and qualifications alone. Often the "beautiful people" are penalized for their attributes by the not so "fortunate"... when the do have the qualifications! This ugly battle (pun intended) rears itself all to often for women in the workplace and has often caused much heartache and outcasting for the women who possess beauty & brains. If there is a solution to this would BNT please post it!!! I've never read or heard about the correct solution!

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement