BNET Insight

The View from Harvard Business

The latest ideas and insights from the minds of Harvard Business.

Brainstorming Doesn't Work -- Here's What Does

December 3rd, 2007 @ 6:13 am

8 Comments

Categories: Research, Strategy

Tags: Product, Strategy, Management, Sean Silverthorne

How many times have you been called into a brainstorming session and encouraged to “think outside the box!” Or maybe your manager assigned you to come up with ideas for improving an existing product.

Do these practices work? Not well.

“The problem with the first method is that most people are not very good at unstructured, abstract brainstorming,” say the authors of a new Harvard Business Review article about generating truly innovative thinking. “The second method — slicing the data in new ways — almost always produces only Brainstorming Doesn’t Work — But Here’s What Doessmall to middling insights…”

So what’s a company that lives by its brains to do? Learn to ask the right questions to get people thinking in ways that are truly productive. One example the authors use is to ask participants to answer a narrower question, one that takes a path somewhere in between rigid analysis and boundless speculation.

Example: What product can we take from our childhood and transform into a more extreme, expensive form for adults?

This question has led to such products as Rollerblades, Häagen-Dazs ice cream, and Spider-Man movies, the authors say. “The same notion has led to over 25 new product categories, including gourmet jelly beans, baseball fantasy camps, $200 sneakers, 20-foot-high sand castles for corporate parties, paintball, space tourism, and Disney collectibles.”

The article lists 21 great questions for developing new products. Here are 5 of them:

  • Who spends at least 50% of what our product costs to adapt it to their specific needs?
  • Who uses our product in ways we never expected or intended?
  • What major breakthroughs in efficiency or effectiveness have we made in our business that could be applied in another industry?
  • What is the biggest hassle of purchasing or using our product?
  • Which technologies embedded in our product have changed the most since the product was last redesigned?

Read the article to see all of the questions, then answer one for us. What questions do you use to get your employees thinking creatively?

(Rollerblading image by Steve Longus, CC 2.0)

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    joyceturk.artist@...

    12/05/07 | Report as spam

    thinking creatively

    How does a right-brained creative employee who thinks out of the box manage an extremely left-brained narrowly focused office director?

  •  
    2

    fhkchen

    03/24/08 | Report as spam

    left-brain vs. right-brain

    One possible approach will be to use a rational analogy to convince the left-brained director. This approach is effective since a left-brained creative person often have no problem coming up with an appropriate analogy. Yet, the very left-brained types can appreciate the logic of the argument because an analogy recalls for him/her knowledge that he already understands.

    Frank

  •  
    3

    gerwitz

    03/28/08 | Report as spam

    crucial conversations

    google "crucial conversations."

    I suspect you may have your own issues. Does this left brain really bring
    balance?

    Kurt.Gerwitz.Com

  •  
    4

    dolores.rodgers@...

    12/18/07 | Report as spam

    RE: Brainstorming Doesn't Work -- Here's What Does

    If you could add a new feature to our current service/product, what would it be?

  •  
    5

    AgCreativity

    03/25/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Brainstorming Doesn't Work -- Here's What Does

    Left-brain/right brain=obsolete thinking.
    ----------
    And here's a comment about Brainstorming from the person immersed in this stuff. Too many people misunderstand Brainstorming and have no clue how to make it valuable. It is best as a team building and concensus tool when you have a variety of personality types. And it is also a part of proven applied process. However, the money happens when you have the right faclitator leading the session and knows how to design it.

    $$$
    ----------
    Talk to me if you want the research citations.

    AgCreativity

  •  
    6

    mdshaver

    05/09/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Brainstorming Doesn't Work -- Here's What Does

    Most people have become so used to thinking "outside the box" on command that "thinking outside the box" has just become another box. I see a lot of these attitudes:
    (1) I don't get paid to come up with new product ideas, but someone does-let them earn their money.
    (2) I do "lose points" when I sit in a "brainstorming" session and don't have new and wonderful ideas,or,worse, have an idea that gets judged as "inside the box" thinking.
    (3) Good ideas more often occur at random or in some setting that isn't a brainstorming session. If the suggestion box wasn't a joke I would submit ideas-we need a better system to take advantage of random ideas that may be productive.

  •  
    7

    edsley

    05/14/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Brainstorming Doesn't Work -- Here's What Does

    Thats right... i guess sometimes we do get into brainstorming sessions with an agenda
    http://danielsrepublic.com/country/?p=137

  •  
    8

    Stephen6294

    05/21/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Brainstorming Doesn't Work -- Here's What Does

    Brainstorming does work, you just can't go into it cold. It is important to give the participants an agenda or some advance time to consider the issue to be tackled.

    I wrote about this topic here ( http://tinyurl.com/64fhc2 ), it is important to remember that brainstorming isn't something that you just jump into. You also need additional tools:

    "Whether you???re brainstorming ideas, trying to solve a problem or analyzing a situation, ... you can end up spending a huge amount of time trying to assimilate all the little bits and pieces. Rather than letting the disjointed information get the better of you, you can use an affinity diagram to help you organize it.

    An affinity diagram helps to synthesize large amounts of data by finding relationships between ideas. The information is then gradually structured from the bottom up into meaningful groups. From there you can clearly ???see??? what you have, and then begin your analysis or come to a decision."

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
Click Here

Blogger Profiles

  • Blogger Thumbnail Sean Silverthorne Sean Silverthorne is the editor of HBS Working Knowledge, which provides a first look at the research and ideas of Harvard Business School faculty. Working Knowledge, which won a Webby award in 2007, currently records 4 million unique visitors a year. He has been with HBS since 2001. Silverthorne has 28 years experience in print and online journalism. Before arriving at HBS, he was a senior editor at CNet and Executive Editor of ZDNet News.... more »

advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement
Click Here