BNET Insight

Where’s the Line ?

Right and wrong in a for-profit world

CSR-Washing is the New Greenwashing

August 18th, 2008 @ 3:40 pm

2 Comments

Categories: Corporate Responsiblity, Global Trade

Tags: Nike Inc., Starbucks Corp., Whole Foods, CSR-Washing, Corporate Social Responsibility, Sales Strategy, Web 2.0, Business Ethics, Marketing Research, Gender And Diversity

Greenwashing.

It’s such a catchy piece of shorthand. Greenwashing, for those of you who haven’t heard, describes a marketing communications activity that companies engage in when they want to be perceived as ecologically sustainable, even when they’re not. Greenwashing, as the BNET Business Dictionary notes, could amount to, “a false or misleading picture of environmental friendliness given by some organization to conceal its damaging activities.”

But there are – and have been for years – other kinds of “-washing” going on. Take, for example, Big Tobacco’s funding of a “scientific” laboratory in the 1950s that purported to debunk any links between cigarette smoking and lung cancer.

The latest advances in “-washing” have come, not surprisingly, via YouTube. Recent “films” posted to the popular online video sharing site include:

Nike’s “The Girl Effect
This film is designed to demonstrate the sportswear company’s commitment to the economic betterment of women and girls in developing countries. (Nike and its vendors have been accused of exploiting labor in poor nations such as Vietnam and Indonesia.)

Starbucks Invests in Farmer’s Communities
There’s nothing quite like happy people in bright native headgear picking coffee beans in the shadows of Kilimanjaro and enjoying water from a new plantation-funded cistern to take attention off the fact that the about only people getting rich off of Starbucks coffee are the company’s execs and coffee plantation owners.

Whole Foods’ “Whole Earth Generation” Series
Among other things, like buying its organic produce and all-natural turkey jerky, Whole Foods would very much like it if you would convert your diesel vehicle to run on used vegetable oil. Presumably, this should alleviate some of your guilt the next time you take home one of Whole Foods’ large, organic soups in a waxed paper container. Heck, the company even has a YouTube channel all its own, where you can enjoy a virtual visit to a Whole Foods market, not in the company of a sales person, but of a Guest Services Ambassador.

These companies, and many others, are using Web 2.0 tools to try to show their commitment to “corporate social responsibility,” or “CSR .” Maybe some such commitments are genuine, and maybe some are less so. Whatever the case, we need to come up with a new buzzword for when a company shamelessly touts its CSR efforts, because “CSR-washing” doesn’t exactly roll trippingly off the tongue.

We’re taking suggestions.

Have a workplace ethical dilemma you'd like to share and discuss with BNET readers?

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    sbrennaman354

    08/19/08 | Report as spam

    RE: CSR-Washing is the New Greenwashing

    CSR - Customer Service Representative - oops wrong industry (Banking). Whenever I hear or read "Green" in an advertisement I apply more than a "grain of salt" when attempting to ferret out the accuracy or efficacy of the message from the company. Like many charitable or not-for-profit organizations where only a small percentage of the proceeds actually go to the charity/mission; consumers need to apply common sense (NOT SO COMMON, Voltaire) when purchasing a product or applying loyalty. As in charities what you are buying may be in reality, very distant from what is reality. Claiming and being ???Green??? is attractive but much more expensive and not necessarily the best option (health, cost efficiency, and productivity). But that is another subject for a blog.

  •  
    2

    cirving

    08/19/08 | Report as spam

    RE: CSR-Washing is the New Greenwashing

    As I always do with all problems in business and life is try to find the root cause and find the solution to eliminate the root cause. In this case seems to me that CSR Washing is the effect of two ingredients combined:

    1.- Poor management - corporations going for the mony regardless of what they have to do to make it.

    2.- Poor Governments - All excesses of corporations in their home countries and abroad are the effect of corruption and irresponsible goverments who allow these bad practices, environmental, labor, etc.

    All of us can contribute to eliminate the root cause, in the cases listed above, we can start by NOT buying their products, the day we stop buying all their goods, will be the day they will start taking positive actions towards eliminating these unethical and environmentally damaging practices.

    Thanks for listing these companies more often, I suggest to make a CSR score that allows consumers to know where the companies we are buying from are today.

    Thanks

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
Top Rated
    advertisement
    • Click Here
    • Click Here
    • Click Here
    advertisement