BNET Insight

Where’s the Line ?

Right and wrong in a for-profit world

Student Loan Business: An Ethical Dilemma in the Credit Crunch

June 3rd, 2008 @ 11:33 am

7 Comments

Categories: Client Relationships, Ethics, Personal Conduct, Polls

Tags: Lender, Student, Business Ethics, Blogging, Games, Strategy, Leadership, Management, Internet, Personal Technology

The student loan business is going through a credit crisis, and some of the nation’s largest lenders are responding with a new business model that may be sound business but is ethically questionable.

Students at the top-tier schools are being taken care of, but those at the lower-rung — community colleges, and other less-competitive institutions — are being dissed in the lending game, whether by being dropped by lenders or being forced to take packages that are far-less appealing than their ivory tower peers.

The thinking is simple: the better the school, the more money that student is likely to make in the long-term, which means you’ll get a more solid return on the loan. But what about the ethics here? Are these large lenders discriminating against a large economic chunk of the population? I think so, because the nation’s neediest students are the ones most likely to be hurt. Community college may not be a stepping stone for the corner office, but it is an invaluable stepping stone to a better job and a better life for the less fortunate.

The tag line for this blog is “right and wrong in a for-profit world.” This is exactly that kind of dilemma. What’s right for profit may not be ethically sound. So, are these large lenders in the wrong here?

Are the lenders behaving unethically in this situation?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Is this right, wrong, or simply inevitable? Leave your thoughts in the comments section.

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    presenter

    06/03/08 | Report as spam

    Business reality & Greater Good

    I really wonder where this line comes from... 'This is a situation where business reality outweighs the greater good' and exactly the 'wrong' attitude to take in these present times. HOW CAN business reality ever outweigh the Greater GOOD? We have seen Business reality strip our Planet of 'free' ores and fuels, all sold through profitable corporations, exploiting their suppliers and fleecing their customers.. that is what happens when business reality 'outweighs' the greater good - or rather, I want more so you have to put up with less.....

  •  
    2

    markoy

    06/04/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Student Loan Business: An Ethical Dilemma in the Credit Crunch

    I see nothing wrong here, except maybe tying value to the reputation of the institution. Many scholarships require consistent academic performance in order to keep one's grant. Why not a similar approach here? The higher your GPA the more favorable terms you earn on your loan.

  •  
    3

    studioantix@...

    06/04/08 | Report as spam

    education for all

    Refusing loans to students who are in lower-tier schools or community colleges is unethical because it discourages education for all. One of the greatest aspects of the US is the ability to change your career at any time through education, which isn't an option in other countries. Education is considered a key factor in improving society: better-educated people make better-informed decisions. Furthermore, not permitting students an alternative path to success except through the highest GPA's and the elitest schools promotes a homegeneity that could potentially result in a stagnant society of haves versus have-nots, rather than a diverse, vibrant one with varying strata.

  •  
    4

    Hajnal

    06/04/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Student Loan Business: An Ethical Dilemma in the Credit Crunch

    Not only is this type of discrimination (based on income) repulsive and unacceptable, but so is the assumption that the better the school, the more likely the students will make more money to pay back the loans. I have student loans, and it turns out, even a high-priced Engineering education cannot provide enough to pay back those loans (with an interest rate twice that of my mortgage), particularly with a young family. Perhaps what was expected of me is to pay those loans for 10 more years and have children well passed 35 (which by the way is not recommended.) No matter how we look at student loans, the core idea is noble (how else would poor people ever get educated?), but the way it is being executed is plain wrong and as I see, things are only going to get worse.

  •  
    5

    bmkosiorek

    06/04/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Student Loan Business: An Ethical Dilemma in the Credit Crunch

    This is another case of the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer. How are underpriveleged kids suppose to have any sort of chance at changing their destiny in life if they can't get a good education?

  •  
    6

    d_user_name

    06/04/08 | Report as spam

    RE: Student Loan Business: An Ethical Dilemma in the Credit Crunch

    The problem here -- nominally the preservation of capital -- is not really, or at least not only, the problem. The problem is we have two yardsticks (education = good, profit = good) and we're, in effect, forcing a for-profit entity to adopt aprofitable ethics. That's contradictory at best and more likely impossible.

  •  
    7

    kstew0572

    06/25/08 | Report as spam

    What????

    Just because a person goes to a community college does not mean that they get lower grades.
    What these lenders are doing is not only unecthical, it is redlining.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
Click Here
Top Rated
    advertisement
    • Click Here
    • Click Here
    • Click Here
    advertisement