BNET Insight

The Corner Office

Taking on the big questions facing CEOs, boards, and shareholders.

4 Work-Arounds to the H1B Problem

May 6th, 2008 @ 2:17 pm

6 Comments

Categories: Best Practices, Hiring, Management, Regulation, Technology

Tags: U.S., Visa, Worker, H1B, TN Visa, L-1 Visa, E-3 Visa, E Category Visas, Free Trade, Finance

CEOs, especially those involved in high tech, see the same pattern year after year. They desperately need high-level, foreign workers since universities in the U.S. are not turning out enough software writers and computer engineers.

Yet nothing ever seems to get done in Congress to boost the number of H1B visas for desirable and skilled tech workers beyond the annual limit of 65,000 which are in such demand that they often “sell out” in one day each April.

This year, demand was so strong for skilled tech workers from, especially fromĀ India, Pakistan, and China, that the federal government staggered its allocation period over one week ending April 7. Some 163,000 applications came for 65,000 H1B visas and 20,000 more visas for foreigners with advanced degrees, according to Paul Colman, director of Chicago-based VISANOW. All were briskly snapped up.

Year after year, CEOs and other high level executives from such marquee-name tech firms as Sun Microsystems, Microsoft, 3com and Motorola lobby for a more generous and rational policy to allow needed foreign workers in through the H1B and L1 visa programs. “Almost every year, there seems to be the same lip service about the need for more visas,” Colman says.

As before, there are fresh attempts to rationalize the H1B visa system. U.S. Rep. Lamar Smith, a Texas Republican, for instance, has proposed laws raising the annual H1B limits from 65,000 to 195,000 in 2008 and 2009. The sad part is that with presidential elections underway and the politicized fervor over “illegal” and mostly Latino immigration, the likelihood of new policy changes are remote. So, we’re stuck with the current, dysfunctional system for at least another year.

Colman says his group advises business clients to look beyond strict H1B versions. These include:

    1. TN Category Visa: Based on the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), this visa is available to Canadian and Mexican citizens coming to the U.S. to perform professional activities. The TN visa has a one year term, but can be renewed indefinitely. There is no cap on the number of TN visas allotted.
    2. L Category Visa: These allow companies to hire foreign employees on a temporary basis with the ability to provide permanent residency. The L-1 visa is available if a company is affiliated with a foreign operation. To be eligible, employees must have worked for the foreign company for at least one of the last three years.
    3. O Category Visa: Visas in this category are used for business and science professionals that exhibit extraordinary ability in their fields. The initial visa is valid for up to three years and can be renewed indefinitely for up to one year each time it is renewed
    4. E Category Visa: Created for foreign workers from countries that signed the Friendship, Commerce, Navigation (FCN) treaty with the U.S. The E-2 visa is available to nationals of FCN treaty countries that have made a significant investment within the United States. The E-3 visa is specifically for Australians who intend on working in the U.S. temporarily in a specialty occupation. E category visas are valid for two years and can be renewed indefinitely.

      How have visa problems affected your firm?

      Have a tidbit of executive wisdom you would care to share with fellow BNET readers?

       
      Reply to Story

      BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

      Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

      •  
        1

        tstamant

        05/07/08 | Report as spam

        You can't be serious

        I know several highly educated software engineers, programmers and IT people that are out of work due to this "H1B problem". Bringing these people in from India, Pakistan, etc has nothing to do with the availability of similar talent in the U.S, and everything to do with cheap disposable labor.

      •  
        2

        gisellepg

        05/09/08 | Report as spam

        H1-B workers

        Not sure if I agree. We have spent more time and resources recruiting for positions in IT fields thatn any other field relative to our business. It has been my experience that you find a lot more foreign nationals that possess the skills and abilities for these positions. For example, my organization had a digital processor position available last year. This position would have to use 3-d digital imaging software to read and devise architectural floor plans for future project construction. Courses to learn use of this software is just recently being offered in the US. We found a young lady that needed an H1-B and gladly waited for 6 months before she could begin working. It seemed like our recruitment initiative for this position was somewhat of a revolving door!

      •  
        3

        zincmet

        05/07/08 | Report as spam

        RE: 4 Work-Arounds to the H1B Problem

        Others may see me as Xenophobic. However, I wonder if the phrase "desirebale and skilled tech workers" really means "cheap and easily intimidated."

      •  
        4

        nlfre@...

        05/07/08 | Report as spam

        H1B

        Intimidated? Really? LOL!

      •  
        5

        khansy

        05/07/08 | Report as spam

        RE: 4 Work-Arounds to the H1B Problem

        Many companies including Microsoft have started their R&D and development in India and elsewhere, with advanced broad band and internet technologies physical presence hardly makes a difference for both development or support. If there is shortage of IT proffessionals in US, then the companies and the Government should make an effort in IT education through incentives, and transfer of skills for millions who are loosing their jobs in automotive and other sectors due to the economic downturn, rather than trying to import manpower while natives are jobless.

      •  
        6

        ayeuchyk

        05/07/09 | Report as spam

        RE: 4 Work-Arounds to the H1B Problem

        I am graduating next week from Binghamton University, and so frustrated with H1B situation.
        Next year it will be even worse: most of this year International Grads are unlikely to find H1B sponsors, plus, next year grads will kill our chances when our Optional Practical Training visa expires. Going back home? With $35K debt, not only ne but my whole family would not be able to pay it off in decades! I am using that website to apply for Canadian Permanent Resident Card.

        Check out that place: http://www.geth1bcanada.webs.com/

        I think it is the least risky solution.
        I cannot allow myself to take the risk of finishing my OPT and get to a dead end next year.

        What do you think? Thanks for advice and support.

        Alex, 2009 MBA Grad

      Please add your comment:

      1. You are currently: a Guest |
      2.  

      Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

      advertisement
      Click Here
      advertisement
      • Click Here
      • Click Here
      • Click Here
      advertisement